Client Alert

Deferred Compensation Plans To Undergo Major Changes Under American Jobs Creation Act of 2004


President Bush is expected to sign the American Jobs Creation Act of 2004 ("AJCA"), which contains many significant tax law changes, including the most sweeping change to income tax rules related to deferred compensation in over 25 years. This legislation will require virtually all non-qualified deferred compensation plans to be reviewed, and will require most of them be revised to meet the requirements of the new law.

In general, AJCA adds rules to regulate:

  • The date by which deferred compensation elections must be made;

  • The permissible dates on which deferred compensation may be paid to employees; and

  • Timing rules for changing distribution elections.

Plans and Arrangements Subject to New Law. The law applies to all non-qualified deferred compensation plans and arrangements, whether elective or non-elective, including traditional deferred compensation plans, supplemental executive retirement plans (SERPs), and, in some cases, employment agreements and severance plans. The new rules do not apply to qualified pension or 401(k) plans or to bona fide vacation leave, sick leave, compensatory time, disability pay, death benefits or bonuses paid within 2 ½ months following the end of a calendar year.

Note: The AJCA is not limited to the employer-employee relationship. It also applies to deferrals made under plans and arrangements for non-employees such as directors, consultants, and independent contractors.

Equity Compensation Awards. The new rules also apply to equity compensation awards deferring the receipt of compensation, other than incentive stock options (ISOs), options granted under employee stock purchase plans (ESPPs) and nonqualified stock options with an exercise price equal to or greater than the fair market value of the stock on the date of grant. This means that discounted stock options, stock appreciation rights (SARs) and restricted stock are covered under the new rules.

Effective Date of New Rules. The new law applies to all amounts payable to a participant from a deferred compensation plan after December 31, 2004, unless (1) the participant is vested in such amounts by December 31, 2004, and (2) the plan is not materially amended after October 3, 2004. Under the Conference Committee Report that accompanied AJCA, the Internal Revenue Service has 60 days after the enactment of AJCA to issue rules allowing a period within which plans can be revised to meet the requirements of AJCA.

Major Deferred Compensation Provisions of AJCA

Date by Which Employees Must Make Deferred Compensation Elections

Basic Rule: Under AJCA, an employee must generally make an election to defer the receipt of compensation in the year prior to the year in which the employee earns such compensation.

Example: To defer amounts that an employee earns in 2005, the employee must make an election to defer receipt of such amount by December 31, 2004, even if the employee will not actually receive such amount until 2006 in the absence of the election. An initial election to defer compensation must specify the timing of the distribution (see Paragraph B. below) and the form of the distribution (e.g. lump sum, installments or annuity).

First Exception to Basic Rule: A participant who is newly eligible in a plan during a calendar year has until 30 days after such initial eligibility to make an election, but only with respect to amounts earned after the date the election is made.

Second Exception to Basic Rule: For certain performance based compensation for which the performance period is at least one year; the employee has until six months prior to the end of the performance period to make a deferred compensation election. The IRS is required to publish rules defining "performance based compensation" to which this exception will apply. The House and Senate Conferees expect that the IRS definition of performance based compensation for this purpose will be similar (but not identical) to the definition of performance based compensation under Section 162(m) of the Internal Revenue Code (the $1 million limit on deductible compensation to executives).

Date by Which Amounts Deferred Must be Distributed to Employees

In general, amounts cannot be distributed to employees from a deferred compensation plan under AJCA before the earliest of:

  1. The employee's separation from service (to be defined by the IRS), with a six-month delay in the case of a "key employee" of a public company (Very generally, "key employees" are the 50 highest paid employees of the employer.);

  2. The employee's death;

  3. The employee's disability (as defined in the statute);

  4. An unforeseeable emergency (i.e. a "hardship withdrawal," as defined in the statute);

  5. A change in control of the employee's employer (to be defined by the IRS); or

  6. A specified time (in general, a date certain, not the occurrence of an event such as the date the employee's child enters college).

Note: These new distribution rules will prohibit many distribution options that have been standard in deferred compensation plans for years. For example, AJCA will prohibit a SERP from distributing amounts to a participant based on when the participant elects to receive a distribution from a qualified pension or 401(k) plan. AJCA will also prohibit in-service distributions in which a part of the benefit is forfeited (often 10%) (sometimes called a "haircut distribution").

Changes to Distribution Date

Under AJCA an employee is permitted to change a distribution date he or she originally elected only if:

  1. The new election does not cause a distribution to occur sooner than it would have under original distribution election (except as provided otherwise by Treasury regulations);

  2. The employee's election of a new distribution date is not effective until at least one year after the employee makes the new election.

  3. In the case of an election for a distribution to occur at a specified time (see 6. above), the first payment under the new election occurs no sooner than one year after the date the new election is made; and

  4. The new distribution date is at least five years after the original distribution date, unless the new election is for a distribution on account of the employee's death, disability or an unforeseen emergency.
Rabbi Trusts

AJCA imposes substantial limitations on viability of off-shore rabbi trusts as funding mechanisms for deferred compensation plans. Off-shore rabbi trusts are employed to protect deferred compensation assets while still conforming to the IRS's mandate that these assets generally be available to satisfy the claims of the plan sponsor's creditors. Although these trusts are nominally available to the plan sponsor's creditors, local law may make it impractical or impossible for the creditors to gain access to the assets they hold. Under AJCA, deferred compensation assets that are held in or transferred to an offshore rabbi trust will be taxed to employees to the extent they are vested in such amounts.

In addition, AJCA limits the use of "springing" trusts to protect deferred compensation assets in the event of a plan sponsor's financial distress. The inclusion of, any provision in a trust that restricts access to the assets of the trust upon any trigger related to the financial health of the employer will cause employees to be taxed on the amount of their vested deferred compensation benefits held in the trust even if the triggering event never occurs.

Penalties for Non-Compliance

Employees with benefits under deferred compensation plans that do not meet the requirements of AJCA will be taxed on the amount of their deferred compensation at the later of the year in which the violation occurred, or the year in which the employee becomes vested in such amounts. In the case of any violation, the employee must also pay an excise tax equal to 20% of the amount of deferred compensation required to be taken into income. Finally, to any extent the tax is not paid in the year in which the plan is first out of compliance, interest accrues at the statutory rate for underpayments of tax plus 1%.

Note: This penalty applies on an individual basis. For example, if a participant is permitted to accelerate the timing of his distribution but the plan itself does not generally make this option available, the AJCA penalty provisions should only be applicable to that participant and should not generally impact the plan or its other participants.

Action Items

In response to AJCA, employers may wish to:

  1. Inventory Plans. Employers should find and list all plans, arrangements and agreements they sponsor or are parties to that could be affected by AJCA. Such plans should then be reviewed to determine whether, and to what extent, the new rules under AJCA could affect such plans and arrangements.

  2. Revise Plan Documents. After determining which plans are impacted by the new rules under AJCA, the employer should have such plans revised accordingly within the deadlines prescribed by the IRS. As mentioned above, the IRS is required to issue rules within sixty days of the law's enactment on the dates within which plans must be revised to meet AJCA.

  3. Consider New Distribution Options. In designing or revising any plan, employers should consider to what extent certain distribution options should simply be "hard-wired" into the plan document, or to what extent employees should be counseled about the possible effects of their deferral elections. Unless the IRS issues clarifying guidance, it is possible that some distribution options not elected with respect to deferred compensation in an initial election will not, as a practical matter, be available in a later election with respect to that deferred compensation.

  4. Planning Opportunities Before 12/31/2004. Although the effective dates established under AJCA limit planning opportunities, to reduce or avoid the impact of new rules under AJCA, employers maintaining non-elective deferred compensation plans may wish to consider whether to extend a vested benefit to a participant prior to January 1, 2005, assuming that can be accomplished under the terms of the plan as it existed on October 3, 2004.

In addition, any election to defer amounts that will be earned after December 31, 2004 should be undertaken cautiously to take into account the new rules, including the possibility, mentioned in Paragraph 3. above, that certain distribution dates not elected in an employee's initial deferral election, may not be correctible by making a later election.




Unsolicited e-mails and information sent to Morrison & Foerster will not be considered confidential, may be disclosed to others pursuant to our Privacy Policy, may not receive a response, and do not create an attorney-client relationship with Morrison & Foerster. If you are not already a client of Morrison & Foerster, do not include any confidential information in this message. Also, please note that our attorneys do not seek to practice law in any jurisdiction in which they are not properly authorized to do so.