Sometimes, a class representative’s strategic decision to forgo claims or legal theories may help secure class certification. But what if the legal theories left on the cutting-room floor could support stronger claims for some class members (including the representative herself)? In Nolen v. PeopleConnect, Inc., 192 F.4th 1065 (9th Cir. 2026), the Ninth Circuit affirmed class certification while offering guidance on when such tactical decisions may render a lead plaintiff’s representation inadequate. Its discussion highlights the possible tradeoffs between Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23’s requirements: Where a class representative’s strategic choices create a serious enough intraclass conflict, finding predominance or commonality may create an adequacy problem.
Read the full blog post.