Morrison Foerster is an international law firm with lawyers practicing throughout the United States, Asia, and Europe. Click to discover more.

mofo_share_image.jpg

Morrison Foerster

common-default.jpeg

Terms / Notices

Cookies

Privacy Policy

Reporting Hotline

Attorney Advertising

Alumni

  Linkedin

MoFo LinkedIN

  Facebook

MoFo Facebook

YouTube

MoFo Youtube

Morrison Foerster - Footer

No-Poach Case Alert: DOJ’s No-Poach Strategy Dealt Another Blow As Court Tosses Case Before It Reaches Jury

You have not solved the recaptcha challenge yet or session expired, try again.

Email Disclaimer

Disclaimer

Unsolicited e-mails and information sent to Morrison Foerster will not be considered confidential, may be disclosed to others pursuant to our <a href="https://www.mofo.com/about/privacy-policy.html">Privacy Policy</a>, may not receive a response, and do not create an attorney-client relationship with Morrison Foerster. If you are not already a client of Morrison Foerster, do not include any confidential information in this message. Also, please note that our attorneys do not seek to practice law in any jurisdiction in which they are not properly authorized to do so.

Feedback

mofo-logo-2022.svg

People

Capabilities

Resources

About

Community

Offices

Careers

Stay Connected

The U.S. Department of Justice’s (“DOJ’s”) ongoing efforts against no-poach agreements suffered their latest setback on April 28, 2023

<h3>Sorry, we weren’t able to find the terms you entered.</h3>Please try a different term or keyword.

People

Capabilities

Resources

Not Found Cards

We are Morrison Foerster — a global firm of exceptional credentials. Our clients include some of the largest financial institutions, investment banks, and Fortune 100, technology, and life sciences companies. Our lawyers are committed to achieving innovative and business-minded results for our clients, while preserving the differences that make us stronger.Because of the generality of this update, the information provided herein may not be applicable in all situations and should not be acted upon without specific legal advice based on particular situations. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

About Morrison Foerster

people-default-header-desktop.jpg

people-default-header-mobile.jpg

Default Meta Data

The U.S. Department of Justice’s (“DOJ’s”) ongoing efforts against no-poach agreements suffered their latest setback on April 28, 2023, following the Connecticut federal court’s ruling in U.S.A. v. Mahesh Patel, acquitting all six defendants of criminal liability for allegedly entering into a horizontal no-hire agreement. Though it is tied to the particular facts of the case, the ruling is yet another sign that the DOJ continues to face an uphill battle to impose criminal liability on what typically has been a civil issue.Read the <a href="https://elc.mofo.com/topics/no-poach-case-alert-doj-s-no-poach-strategy-dealt-another-blow-as-court-tosses-case-before-it-reaches-jury" target="_blank">full blog post</a>.

No-Poach Case Alert: DOJ’s No-Poach Strategy Dealt Another Blow As Court Tosses Case Before It Reaches Jury

Sign Up

Eric Akira Tate chairs the firm’s Global Employment and Labor Group. He represents technology and other companies in bet-the-company trade secrets and employee mobility cases. Eric also represents boards of directors and companies in #MeToo and other sensitive internal investigations and disputes with executives, whistleblower, wrongful termination, discrimination and harassment, and other employment litigation.Eric also advises companies in employment law compliance and transactional matters, including restrictive covenants and other personnel policies and procedures, and employment aspects of mergers and acquisitions throughout the United States and globally.Eric’s recent board of directors and executive dispute matters include: defending a publicly traded UK company in the defense of a wrongful termination suit by the former CEO of its U.S. subsidiary; representing a TSX-traded Canadian company in wrongful termination and other claims alleged by two terminated C-suite executives; represented a publicly traded Japanese investment firm in separation of a C-suite executive; represented a publicly traded Japanese healthcare company in the separation of the CEO and 20+ other U.S. executives, including defense of several wrongful termination and discrimination claims; and represented a publicly traded Fortune 200 technology company in investigation of discrimination and harassment claims against a C-suite executive, who subsequently resigned without incident. Regarding trade secrets and employee mobility issues, Eric represented Uber in its diligence investigation as part of its acquisition of Ottomotto, the autonomous vehicle startup founded by former Google engineers. He then helped lead Uber’s defense of the subsequent patent infringement and trade secrets misappropriation suit, which settled several days into trial in February 2018. In addition to technology companies, Eric has handled similar matters for companies across many industries, including, but not limited to, Williams Sonoma v. Restoration Hardware, International Lease Finance Co. v. Air Lease Corporation, Melaleuca, Inc. v. Shaklee Corporation, and New Century Mortgage v. Encore Credit.Most recently, Eric was recognized by Chambers USA for Labor & Employment, again by Best Lawyers as a leading lawyer in employment law, again by the Daily Journal as one of California’s Top Labor and Employment Lawyers and Top Trade Secrets Lawyers, again by Benchmark Litigation as a Labor and Employment Star, and again named to Law360’s 2023 EA Discrimination Editorial Advisory Board. Eric was elected as a Fellow of the College of Labor and Employment Lawyers in 2021.Eric is committed to advancing diversity, equity, and inclusion at the firm and development of the legal profession generally. Eric has served on the firm’s Diversity Strategy Committee since its inception and is a past co-chair. Eric is a former hiring partner for the Palo Alto office and past member of the firmwide Pro Bono and Litigation Evaluations Committees. Eric serves on the Points Committee for the firm. Eric serves as a partner sponsor for multiple affinity groups at the firm and as a formal and informal mentor to associates around the firm. Eric is a leader in the American Bar Association’s (ABA’s) Labor and Employment (LEL) Section and LEL’s Employment Rights and Responsibilities (ERR) Committee. Eric is serving his second term on the governing Council (Board of Directors) for the LEL Section. Eric serves as co-chair of ERR’s Covenants Not to Compete and Trade Secrets Subcommittee. Eric is a past co-chair of the ABA LEL Annual Meeting Committee, the LEL Section Annual CLE Conference, and ERR’s Alternative Dispute Resolution, Employment At-Will and Collateral Torts, and Worker Dislocation Subcommittees. He also has served on the Planning Committee for the National Employment Law Council’s Annual Conference.For nearly 15 years, Eric has served as a mediator for the Northern District of California’s Alternative Dispute Resolution Program, handling employment discrimination and harassment, wrongful termination, trade secrets and employee mobility, and other employment-related and disability matters.Additionally, Eric is a thought leader in various employment law areas and recognized authority in trade secrets and employee mobility. He serves on the Board of Review for leading BNA treatises Trade Secrets: A State-by-State Survey; Covenants Not to Compete; Employee Duty of Loyalty; and Tortious Interference in the Employment Context. He is author of “Protecting Investment in IP and People” in Today’s General Counsel; “SCOTUS Poised to Resolve Circuit Split on SOX Federal Whistleblower Standard and Other Statutes” in the Daily Journal; “Workplace Bias and Gender Pay Equity in the Silicon Valley” in LJN Employment Law Strategist; “Trade Secrets and the Activision Case: Lessons for Employers and Employees” in the IP Litigator; “Protect Your Investments: Recent Developments in California Law Regarding Non-competition Agreements and Other Restrictive Covenants” in NVCA Today; “Microinequities: Can Bad Behavior Be Actionable?” in National Law Journal; “The When, Who and How of Workplace Investigations” in The Practical Litigator; and “California Raises Bar for Employers Again: Gender Pay Bias Claims Set to Take Off with New Gender Pay Equity and Anti‑Discrimination Law” in Bloomberg BNA Daily Labor Report.Eric is active in community endeavors. He founded and is a former president of the Board of Directors of Hapa Issues Forum, Inc., a nonprofit community organization that addresses issues relating to persons of partial Asian descent. Eric is a past president of the Board of Directors of the Japanese Cultural and Community Center of Northern California. He also is a member of the INROADS Alumni Association, The National Black Lawyers Top 100, the 100 Black Men of the Bay Area, Inc., and he has served as a mentor for students in the Level Playing Field Institute’s IDEAL Scholars Program.A representative sampling of Eric’s key matters is further below.<h4 dir="ltr">Trade Secrets and Employee Mobility Litigation</h4><ul dir="ltr"><li>Defending leading multi-cloud security and application management company in federal court lawsuit by competitor alleging trade secrets misappropriation, various employment-related contract and tort claims, and copyright and trademark violations based on alleged conduct in Russia and California.</li><li>Represented industry-leading enterprise data cloud company in multiple trade secrets and employee mobility lawsuits against former employees and competitor, including obtaining TRO on behalf of client enforcing restrictive covenants against Georgia employee and successfully opposing motions to dismiss and motions to stay in various actions.</li><li>Represented leading shared electric vehicle company in federal court lawsuit alleging against its former head of supply engineering and his new employer trade secrets misappropriation and related claims involving the downloading of thousands of our client’s files upon resignation.</li><li>Represented Springshot in federal court lawsuit to invalidate non-competition agreement that the former employer, Georgia-based INFORM Software, of its newly hired Chief Commercial Officer, sought to enforce to bar the CCO from working for Springshot. </li><li>Represented veterinary orthopedics client in federal court lawsuit against the founder of an acquired company over the enforcement of restrictive covenants, resulting in entry of a permanent injunction enforcing our client’s non-compete agreement against the founder.</li><li>Represented leading cloud computing and virtualization technology company in breach of duty and breach of contract lawsuit against departed executive.</li><li>Represented Fortune 50 corporation in trade secret and employee- and customer-raiding lawsuit against former co-founder and top executives who launched a competing business that achieved a nearly $1 billion IPO.</li><li>Represented international virtualization software company in trade secret misappropriation and employee- and customer-raiding lawsuit against several former executives.</li><li>Represented North American provider of IT solutions and services in series of lawsuits across the United States to combat alleged employee- and customer-raiding activities by competitor.</li><li>Defended investment bank in lawsuit involving enforceability of departing executive’s post-termination non‑competition agreement.</li><li>Represented pharmaceutical company in trade secret misappropriation lawsuit against former finance employee.</li><li>Represented international video game maker in trade secret misappropriation lawsuits against former executives and new competing business.</li><li>Defended national mortgage company in trade secret misappropriation and employee- and customer-raiding lawsuit filed by competitor.</li><li dir="ltr">Defended North American home furnishings retail chain in trade secret misappropriation and employee‑raiding lawsuit filed by competitor.</li></ul><h4 dir="ltr">Board of Directors, Investigations, and Whistleblower and other Employment Dispute Matters</h4><ul><li>Represented board of directors of NASDAQ-traded technology company in negotiation of CEO employment agreement.</li><li>Represented board of directors of publicly traded energy company in negotiation of separation agreement with CEO in context of proxy fight with activist investor.</li><li>Represented Fortune 500 semiconductor company in negotiation of separation agreement of incumbent CEO and employment agreement with new CEO.</li><li>Represented Japanese exchange listed healthcare company in the separation of its CEO and 20+ other U.S. executives, including defense of several wrongful termination and discrimination claims.</li><li>Represented Japanese exchange listed investment firm in separation of a C-suite executive.</li><li>Representing Canadian exchange listed company in wrongful termination and other claims alleged by two terminated C-suite executives.</li><li>Defending U.K. exchange listed company in the defense of federal court wrongful termination suit filed by the former CEO of its U.S. subsidiary.</li><li>Represented publicly traded Fortune 200 technology company in investigation of discrimination and harassment claims against C-suite executive, who subsequently resigned without incident.</li><li>Obtained complete defense award on behalf of technology company in suit filed by former co-founder alleging that the company failed to repurchase upon termination restricted stock valued at more than $5 million.</li><li>Defended pre-IPO biotech company in wrongful termination suit by former co-founder and CEO terminated by board of directors.</li><li>Advised board of directors of leading IT infrastructure company in termination of CEO and CFO of U.S. subsidiary after misconduct investigation and represented board of directors in follow-on wrongful termination claims by CEO and CFO.</li><li>Investigated claims by in-house lawyer that public technology company executives engaged in sexual harassment and national origin discrimination and represented company in successful pre-litigation resolution of claims.</li><li>Investigated and advised board of directors of pre-IPO biotech company on #MeToo allegations regarding top executives.</li><li>Represented publicly traded pharmaceutical industry company in investigation and resolution of whistleblower claims by CFO.</li><li>Obtained complete dismissal in favor of publicly traded gig economy company of discrimination and wrongful termination claims by alleged whistleblower engineer.</li><li>Obtained complete walkaway voluntary dismissal of sexual harassment and discrimination claims by former accounting employee against venture capital and property management company after years of litigation.</li><li>Represented publicly traded technology company in investigation and resolution of alleged revenue and expense reimbursement irregularities involving top sales executive.</li><li>Defended venture capital fund in pregnancy discrimination and restrictive covenant lawsuit by former partner.</li><li>Defended leading corporate social responsibility company in whistleblower and employment discrimination suit filed by former finance executive.</li><li>Defended international laser and fiber-optics company in suit alleging fraud regarding stock options.</li><li>Defended international video game maker in whistleblower and employment discrimination suit filed by former executive.</li><li>Represented top human resources executive officer in discrimination and retaliation lawsuit premised on alleged toxic workplace culture.</li></ul><h4 dir="ltr">Representative Non-Litigation and Transactional Matters</h4><ul><li>Represented founder of private technology company in negotiation of employment agreement with board of directors.</li><li>Represented CEO in negotiation of executive employment agreement with publicly traded biotech company.</li><li>Represented former Managing Partner in separation from iconic Silicon Valley venture capital firm.</li><li>Represented pre-IPO company CEO/Founder in investigation and defense of potential securities fraud claims.</li><li>Represented minority-shareholder executives in negotiation of employment agreements with foreign buyer of company.</li><li>Revised nationwide restrictive covenant agreements for publicly traded technology company.</li><li>Advised leading venture capital fund on restrictive covenants strategy for fund managers.</li><li>Advised leading technology investment fund in worldwide reduction in force.</li><li>Advised leading digital operations management company in worldwide reduction in force.</li><li>Represented clients in employment aspects of buy-side and sell-side M&A transactions across the world with deal sizes ranging from several billion to millions of dollars.</li></ul><h4 dir="ltr">Wage-and-Hour Class and Representative Actions</h4><ul><li>Defended construction company in purported class action for failure to comply with California wage laws.</li><li>Defended international technology company in collective action alleging failure to accurately pay wages to technicians across the United States.</li><li>Defended national restaurant chain in class action regarding alleged failure to comply with California uniform and other wage laws for 10,000 employees.</li><li>Defended international engineering and construction company in class action regarding alleged failure to comply with California overtime laws.</li><li>Defended landscaping company in class action regarding alleged failure to comply with California meal- and rest-period laws.</li><li>Defended individual directors of bankrupt technology company in suit by former employees for unpaid wages.</li></ul>

Eric Tate

Chair, Global Employment and Labor Practice

Cooper Spinelli is a member of the Litigation Department and part of the firm’s Employment & Labor Group. His practice focuses on trade secrets and restrictive covenants, employee mobility and executive disputes, whistleblower claims, and general business litigation.Cooper has represented clients in both affirmative and defensive trade secret misappropriation and employee mobility cases, including cases involving related IP issues. Cooper has, for example, represented a Fortune 50 company in prosecuting an employee-raiding and computer-fraud case against former high-level executives and managers, resulting in a favorable settlement. Cooper also defended a North American provider of IT solutions and services in a series of putative trade secret and employee mobility cases, helping oversee defensive and affirmative litigation across multiple state and federal jurisdictions. And on behalf of a leading multi-cloud security and application management company, Cooper is defending and has helped secure an initial dismissal of a 12-defendant, 26-cause-of-action case in federal court concerning claims of copyright infringement, fraud, and tortious interference based on alleged conduct in Russia and California.In addition, Cooper has represented companies in highly sensitive matters involving involuntary and negotiated departures of chief executive and other senior officers.Cooper also regularly advises innovative startup companies on a range of employment matters, including restrictive covenant and employee mobility issues, at various stages of their lifecycle.Cooper has also contributed to papers and leading treatises addressing trade secrets, employee mobility, and other related issues, including chapters for leading BNA treatises Trade Secrets: A State-by-State Survey, Covenants Not to Compete, Employee Duty of Loyalty, and Tortious Interference in the Employment Context.Before joining the firm, Cooper was an employment and litigation associate at an AmLaw 100 law firm. Before that, he clerked for the Hon. Steven B. Berlin at the Department of Labor, Office of Administrative Law Judges in San Francisco.Cooper received his J.D. magna cum laude from American University Washington College of Law, where he was elected to the Order of the Coif. During law school, Cooper was a senior editor on the executive board for the Administrative Law Review, the official law journal of the American Bar Association Section of Administrative Law & Regulatory Practice.Cooper received a B.A. with distinction from the University of California, Berkeley.

Cooper Spinelli

Partner

Employment + Labor

Employment Law Commentary